Setting the World Aflame: Divestment, Ethics, and Jesuit Identity at Boston College

  • Maura Lester McSweeney Boston College

Abstract

This paper seeks to determine whether Boston College’s decision to keep its investments in fossil fuel companies is consistent with the ethical responsibilities of a Jesuit university. A student group that advocates for the university’s divestment
has had a troubled relationship with the school’s leadership. The main obstacle has been that the divestment group claims that Boston College’s refusal to divest does not align with the ethics to which it subscribes as a Jesuit and Catholic university.
This inconsistency is particularly striking as Boston College itself has a historical precedent of divesting from a sector of the economy for moral reasons. The Apartheid divestment movement catalyzed the university to develop ethical investment guidelines to ensure that the school’s finances were consistent with its Jesuit mission. Moreover, canon law requires Catholic universities to adhere to Church teaching in all of its commitments and activities. by investing in fossil fuel companies, the University defies the teachings of the encyclical laudato si’, which is an infringement on canon law. This paper is an abridged version of the senior thesis completed for the Perspectives Honors sequence.

Author Biography

Maura Lester McSweeney, Boston College
Maura McSweeney graduated from Boston College in the spring of 2017. She was a perspectives major with a minor in International Studies with a focus on Global Ethics. While at Boston College, she served on the executive board of the Organization of Latin American Affairs and was a leader in BC’s Catholic Relief Services Student Ambassadors group for three years. She was awarded the Archbishop Oscar Romero Scholarship, the Mer Zovko and Paul Chebator Ever to Excel award, and the Finneran Commencement Award during her time at Boston College.

References

Opinions. "LTE: A Letter On Climate Justice From VPSA Barb Jones." The Heights 16 04 2015. Web.

Merrell, Gus. "‘We Don’t Even Go Here’: Boston-Area Protesters Challenge BC’s Divestment Views." The Heights 13 04 2015. Web.

Merrel, Gus. "A Long Road To Recognition Ends For Climate Justice, With A Stipulation." The Heights 17 09 2015. Web.

Holt, Nate. "South African Support Group Coalesces At BC." The Heights 09 10 1978: 1. Web.

Boston College. "A wider horizon: The Monan presidency, 1972-1996." 23 02 2015. Web.

Fitzgerald, Paul. "BC Maintains South African Investments." The Heights 31 03 1980: 1. Web.

University Communications. In Memoriam. 18 03 2017. Web.

White, Patrick. "South African Investment Ties Scrutinized: Corporate Portfolios Under "Orderly Process"." The Heights 09 02 1981: 3. Web.

Boston College. "A wider horizon: The Monan presidency, 1972-1996." 23 02 2015. Web.

University of Minnesota. "The Global Sullivan Principles." n.d. Human Rights Library. Web.

Van Anglen, Jim. "Financial Considerations Cause BC to Divest." The Heights 09 09 1985: 2. Web.

Cahn, Steven. Education and the democratic ideal. Chicago: Nelson-Hall, 1979.

Aristotle. Nichomachean Ethics. New York: Oxford University Press, 2009, 153.

Keller, George. Academic strategy: the management revolution in American higher education. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press, 1983.

Simon, Robert. " A Defense of the Neutral University." Cahn, Steven. Morality, Responsibility, and the University. Temple University Press, 1990.

Walsh, Colleen. "Q&A with Harvard President Drew Faust." Harvard Gazette 17 09 2015. Web.

Satz, Debra. Why some things should not be for sale: the moral limits of markets. New York: Oxford University Press, 2010.

Bowie, Norman. "Lessons for Philosophers from Business Ethics: How Philosophy can get its groove back." Talisse, Robert, Maureen Eckert and Steven Cahn. A teacher's life: essays for Steven M. Cahn. Lanham: Lexington Books, 2009.

Pope Francis. On Care for Our Common Home: Laudato Si’ Encyclical letter. Vatican City: Libreria Editrice Vaticana, 2015.

Yuengert, Mary. "Boston College Speaks Up About Divestment, Climate Justice." The Gavel 11 03 2015. Web.

Acadian. "AAM Launches Emerging Market Fossil Fuel Free Strategy." 12 12 2016. Acadian. Web.

Sudol, Sean. "Divestment is the Best Option." The Heights 24 04 2016. Web.

Office of the Treasurer. Boston College Endowment. 11 03 2014. Web. 03 05 2017.

<http://www-test.bc.edu/offices/endowment/ethicalguidelines.html>.

Office of the Treasurer. Boston College Endowment. 06 01 2016. Web. 03 05 2017. <http://www.bc.edu/offices/endowment.html>.

Published
2018-06-10
How to Cite
Lester McSweeney, M. (2018). Setting the World Aflame: Divestment, Ethics, and Jesuit Identity at Boston College. Elements, 13(2). https://doi.org/10.6017/eurj.v13i2.9950
Section
Articles